Organizing for America | Sheldon Motley's Blog: From Samantha Power's Campaign Memo on Barack Obama's Foreign Policy

From Samantha Power's Campaign Memo on Barack Obama's Foreign Policy

By Sheldon from Doylestown - Aug 3rd, 2007 at 10:02 pm EDT

Also listed in: 10 groups

Comments | Mail to a Friend | Report Objectionable Content

Tags: diplomacy, Foreign policy, international relations, Iraq, Nuclear Weapons, nukes

From the Barack Obama Campaign memo penned by Samantha Power, a former journalist and Harvard professor who is advising the campaign:
August 3, 2007
To: Interested Parties
From: Samantha Power -- Founding Executive Director, Harvard University Carr Center for Human Rights Policy
Re: Conventional Washington versus the Change We Need

"Barack Obama defied conventional wisdom and opposed invading Iraq. He did so at a time when some told him that doing so would doom his political future. He took that risk because he thought it essential that the United States 'finish the fight with bin Laden and al Qaeda.' He warned that a 'dumb war, a rash war' in Iraq would result in an "occupation of undetermined length, at undetermined cost, with undetermined consequences."

"Barack Obama was right; the conventional wisdom was wrong. And today, we see the consequences. Iraq is in chaos. According to the National Intelligence Estimate, the threat to our homeland from terrorist groups is 'persistent and evolving.' Al-Qaeda has a safe-haven in Pakistan. Iran has only grown stronger and bolder. The American people are less safe because of a rash war."

"Diplomacy: For years, conventional wisdom in Washington has said that the United States cannot talk to its adversaries because it would reward them. Here is the result:

'The United States has not talked directly to Iran at a high level, and they have continued to build their nuclear weapons program, wreak havoc in Iraq, and support terror.
The United States has not talked directly to Syria at a high level, and they have continued to meddle in Lebanon and support terror.
The United States did not talk to North Korea for years, and they were able to produce enough material for 6 to 8 more nuclear bombs.

'By any measure, not talking has not worked. Conventional wisdom would have us continue this policy; Barack Obama would turn the page. He knows that not talking has made us look weak and stubborn in the world; that skillful diplomacy can drive wedges between your adversaries; that the only way to know your enemy is to take his measure; and that tough talk is of little use if you're not willing to do it directly to your adversary. Barack Obama is not afraid of losing a PR battle to a dictator - he's ready to tell them what they don't want to hear because that's how tough, smart diplomacy works, and that's how American leaders have scored some of the greatest strategic successes in US history.

'Barack Obama's judgment is right; the conventional wisdom is wrong. We need a new era of tough, principled and engaged American diplomacy to deal with 21st century challenges."

"Nuclear Attacks on Terrorist Targets: For years, Washington's conventional wisdom has held that candidates for President are judged not by their wisdom, but rather by their adherence to hackneyed rhetoric that make little sense beyond the Beltway. When asked whether he would use nuclear weapons to take out terrorist targets in Pakistan and Afghanistan, Barack Obama gave the sensible answer that nuclear force was not necessary, and would kill too many civilians. Conventional wisdom held this up as a sign of inexperience. But if experience leads you to make gratuitous threats about nuclear use - inflaming fears at home and abroad, and signaling nuclear powers and nuclear aspirants that using nuclear weapons is acceptable behavior, it is experience that should not be relied upon.

"Barack Obama's judgment is right. Conventional wisdom is wrong. It is wrong to propose that we would drop nuclear bombs on terrorist training camps in Pakistan, potentially killing tens of thousands of people and sending America's prestige in the world to a level that not even George Bush could take it. We should judge presidential candidates on their judgment and their plans, not on their ability to recite platitudes.

"Vision: American foreign policy is broken. It has been broken by people who supported the Iraq War, opposed talking to our adversaries, failed to finish the job with al Qaeda, and alienated the world with our belligerence."

Reader Comments	Comments RSS
Comments are closed for this post.

Samantha Powers Memo | Report to Admin

By Robert Aug 3rd 2007 at 10:30 pm EDT

This is brilliant! It makes absolute sense!. Why isn't it in every newspaper around the country? Why isn't every T.V. and radio station playing it? I hope you don't mind me copying it and passing it out to everyone with whom I come in contact. If you mind, please inform me by tomorrow morning. If you can't reach me via the blogs, my e-mail is trashea@yahoo.com, my phone number is 1-708-922-3371, and my fax number is
1-708-922-3372. If I don't hear from you by noon tomorrow, Saturday, August 4, 2007 at Central Standard Time (CST) I will begin running it off as flyers to pass out!
Robert Earl Lewis

This Is So Clear | Report to Admin

By Dianne Aug 9th 2007 at 10:12 am EDT

Every paragraph makes sense. Every comment is direct and to the point. It is so clear that elementary school students could benefit from reading it. I'll make sure that everyone that I know does read it.

Alright Samantha Powers, keep writing. I love it!

Peace,
Dianne

This Is So Clear | Report to Admin

By Dianne Aug 9th 2007 at 10:13 am EDT

This is truly "........The Change We Need" | Report to Admin

By Jill 4 Obama Aug 27th 2007 at 9:22 pm EDT

This is truly a remarkable Barack Obama Campaign Memo written by Samantha Power, Founding Executive Director, Harvard University Carr Center for Human Rights Policy.

The accuracy of Barack Obama's judgment for America's future diplomacy is the basis for his decisions and ideas for
our Foreign Policy. That is the experience I want my President to have, the experience that knows we can find a common human dignity in respecting others' enough to listen.
Barack Obama shows the strength and courage of human empathy that is a part of his amazing character of leadership
in a world torn apart by war and disaster.

Content on blogs in My.BarackObama represents the opinions of community members and in no way should be interpreted as endorsed or approved by the campaign.