The responses to my “Series of Questions” illustrate a major problem with progressive activism. That weakness is an excessive reliance on what Ronald Heifetz calls “the old definition of leadership” – that is, “the leader has the answers, the vision, and everything else is a sales job to persuade people to sign up for it.”My first question, which I sent to a number of progressive activists, was:*****Please tell me what you think about the following, which someone else wrote:
As we await a full report on what Barack and his team will do with the campaign organization post-election, my primary concerns can be summarized in three questions:
December 31, 2008
by Wade HudsonIn "The Prophet," Ari Berman reports that a former Democratic National Committee (DNC) official close to the Obama campaign says, "Most of Obama's grassroots infrastructure is going to go to the DNC. That's the prevailing gossip of the past few weeks, and it's been pretty consistent."Primarily merging with the Democratic Party makes sense on a number of levels. But for the Party to help "transform the nation," as Obama affirmed during the campaign, it would have to become much more than a vehicle for elections. It would have to become an activist organization dedicated to fighting for its platform year-round, as discussed in Transforming the Democratic Party.To transform itself, the Party would need to undertake serious, year-round precinct organizing. As TiVo and other technologies enable viewers to avoid television commercials, old-fashioned, door-to-door, face-to-face outreach will become more valuable. Precinct organizers could work within their neighborhood throughout the year -- meeting, contacting, and mobilizing neighbors to strengthen and expand social connections and engage in political action (including voting) and community service. This organizing would involve establishing personal relationships with as many neighbors as possible, while listening closely to their concerns. Methods would include welcoming new arrivals to the neighborhood and encouraging eligible voters to become registered Democrats, vote in elections, and participate in joint political action, hopefully including national actions coordinated by the DNC. These goals would be accomplished by knocking on doors, making phone calls, leaving personal notes, and convening neighborhood gatherings including block parties, house meetings, discussion groups, and other activities. Organizers would recruit neighbors to become part of their team and share the work. On Election Day, teams would monitor the polls to determine who has voted and, before the polls close, contact those who have not. Pertinent information would be fed into the national database.Whether through MyBO and/or the Democratic Party, Barack Obama needs to transition his campaign resources into a strong, independent, grassroots organization that can undertake coordinated, united action nationwide. Countless Obama supporters gave their heart and soul to the campaign because they expected as much, based on statements made by Barack and his staff during the campaign.One such statement was "Obama: The Organizer and the Moment," a post to the official Obama section of a social networking website in early 2008. At the top, this post placed a quote by Barack from his first political campaign, "What if a politician were to see his job as that of an organizer?" The post opened with the following:
As many of you know, Barack Obama started his political journey far away from the confines of the Beltway. As a community organizer on the streets of Chicago's South Side,... That's what Barack Obama has done throughout his life, and that's what this whole campaign has been about. Barack has always been an organizer, and he still is an organizer -- that's how he's inspired millions of people, from myriad social positions, to come together and fight for change… We are training people in all of these states not only to make a difference in this election, but to make a difference in their communities, in a sustained way. Regardless of what happens today and in the days ahead, one thing is clear: Barack Obama hasn't just run a presidential campaign, he's built a genuine grassroots movement. In a single year, Barack Obama -- who started his journey organizing on the South Side -- has organized a broad swath of America.... They are empowered, active participants in the struggle for change and they are not tired. The organizing has just begun.
We now have a new national climate with the election of Barack Obama as President. Obama, with the strategic assistance of Marshall Ganz—an old SNCC and farmworkers’ union organizer—developed very sophisticated mobilizing approaches to build a new kind of electoral machine. It was central to his election. But as he has noted many times, “change comes from below.” Obama will be responsive to the kind of agenda that was expressed in [San Francisco]. It is the responsibility of people on the ground to put that agenda front-and-center before the new administration and before countless municipalities, counties, special districts, school boards, state governments, congress, corporations and major nonprofit organizations. That will require something different from the electoral mobilization organization that played such a large role in electing Obama. And Obama understands this. Asked during the primary whether Martin Luther King would support him or Clinton, he responded, “He wouldn’t support either of us. He’d be out in the streets building an independent social justice movement.” ...Obama’s agenda is a presidential one. Community organizing’s agenda should be to push the president. There will be plenty of people pushing him from Wall Street, the auto industry and others in elite circles. If there is not a countervailing push, organized independently of Obama, hopefully with his blessing, we will be disappointed in him as a President—and will have ourselves to blame (emphasis added).
The national office should establish a mechanism to enable those (local) teams who wish to do so to select representatives to relatively small councils of fellow representatives who would communicate horizontally with one another in a deliberate, thoughtful manner to share reports on their work, ask questions, provide mutual support, and develop recommendations to send upward toward the national office through a layer of such councils (e.g., town/city, intra-state regions, state, regional, national) – so that the national office would pay more attention to recommendations from the national council than they ever could to tens of thousands of recommendations from individual members.
Hello, my name is Susan Pfeifer (many of you may know me as mediasusan2@gmail.com) and I am asking for your vote for the California Democratic Party Central Committee. I have been a home owner in San Francisco and California 12th Assembly District for 30 years and an active Democrat for many years.
In October, 2008 the San Francisco Democratic Party awarded me the 2008 Sue Bierman award as Grass Roots Volunteer of the Year for my activities on behalf of the Obama campaign and the San Francisco Democratic Party.
I was elected an Obama Delegate from the 12th Congressional District to the Democratic National Convention in Denver. I created over 115 volunteer events on www.my.barackobama.com, which prompted the Obama campaign to seat me in the front row at Invesco Field for Obama’s historic acceptance speech in Denver. I have made literally thousands of phone calls, registered voters, walked precincts, been a precinct captain, was the San Francisco weekend phone bank coordinator , and ran the SF Obama campaign satellite phone bank in the Western Addition.
I attended the 2008 California State Democratic Convention as a proxy. I am an active member of the West Side Democratic Club; Sunset Democratic Club, Democracy Action (Alec Bash, President) and an officer with San Francisco for Democracy. Other activities have included setting up voter registration tables all over San Francisco and Daly City where I have registered literally thousands of voters. I believe involvement in the Democratic Party is not a spectator sport so I get out there and make things happen.
I have been endorsed by State Senator Leland Yee, Melanie Nutter (SFDCCC) and Alicia Wang (Vice-Chair of the California Democratic Party). The California Democratic Party needs people with experience and commitment. If elected, I will represent Assembly District 12 with energy, honor and dignity.
The 12th Assembly District Caucus will be:
Sunday, January 11th
Westlake Park - Dolger Center (101 Westlake Blvd. - Daly City)
Sunset Blvd. becomes Westlake Blvd. Westlake Park is about 1/4 mile north of
John Daly Blvd.
Registration: 12 noon - 2 pm
Voting starts at 2 pm
Electing: 6 males + 6 females
You can register early at: www.cadem.org (upper right corner under "Get Involved"). I suggest you pre-register to save time. You may sign in and vote anytime between noon - 2pm and leave - or you may stay for candidate speeches starting after 2pm and vote then. You MUST either be signed in or in line by 2 pm in order to vote.
There will be several candidate slates but you may vote for any 6 male and 6 female candidates you choose.
Please call your Senate and House representatives and ask them to push for the above.
I think we should hold public protests.Please let me know what you think.
Thanks for your time and support,Paul
Folks in my community have wondered why I gave up hours and hours of my time organizing for Obama in terms of creating and hosting events, blogging, participating in events, participating in many Saturdays of October and Tuesdays of October phonebanking in a union office, in someone's home, in a condo, in a real estate office, in Century City Plaza hotel, in doorknocking, in dialoguing with folks. Most of my activities were self-driven by my imagination, but mostly my zeal for the candidate. Why did I do what I did?
Creating Events. Most of my events were either done at my home or a nearby bakery. The preparations to host an event include not just cleaning my house, but also making sure that folks have something to eat. And they are eating not popcorn and coke, but something substantial. And each event is created with a them in mind. Why for goodness's sake, no one is grading me? No one is supervising me.
Ah, but my conscience is. All along I wanted my own brand of Obama events to reflect the wholesome goodness that I see in President Elect Obama, the way he respects the crowds, the way he shows his delight at receiving their handshakes and their hugs.
While he is not with me, I am very conscious that I represent him, displaying a full measure of his goodwill and enthusiasm.
Why: Because ever since I have been a citizen of the United States, born and raised in the Philippines for 18 years, my island birthplace has never left my heart. Its people, my people have always exuded their warmths, their affectionate hearts stay open to strangers, friends, and family. That is what I missed the most of my island homeplace and I try to recreate that with every event I had organized for Obama. To some that are not used to seeing that done usually and repeatedly, it left them suspicious, perhaps she herself is running for office, and even taken aback when I introduce myself as a volunteer commissioner. Their suspicion now becomes fullblown, and no longer restrained in others, they approach me and articulate their own inner suspicions " Are you running for office? " And when I say it did not cross my mind as I have no patience for it, they are just left incredulous. Why would that be? Because, we as a nation has been taught and conditioned to be cynical, to be abrupt, to show our darkest selves, to be cold as if James Bond in Quantum of Solace, coldblooded, icequeens and icekings. But, it is not our true selves. It is not who America truly is.
It is why Senator Barack Obama became a shining light for me. I saw his goodness, his goodwill and wherein he regarded folks not as " fat assed consumers of politics, who can be squeezed for every juice of a dollar ", but as smart, thoughtful citizens who he can dialogue with, who he has to earn their respect, who can be educated, who can understand complex issues, as long as all the elements of those political issues are made transparent to the citizens.
I know I am just describing the atmosphere of an event, how did I manage to discuss my origins, my expectations of my political leaders? Because I am not unipolar, nor a unidimensional person. When you consider island folks, we are truly a complex web of intricacies, we are a network of many dimensions, we are a complex array of friendships, family and togetherness, and when we get excited about one thing, we bring in the entire community with that excitement, we talk to them daily, non-stop until they are with us. When we hold a belief, we not only consider ourselves, but each member of our family, each member of our community, where each one is a leader, where each one is a learner, where each one is a teacher, a true full circle and collection of smarts, talents and abilities.
Intellectual Content and Democratic Process. That is what I painstakingly tried to create during the campaign, as soon as I started January 2008. I have not quite stopped doing it. I also wanted the intellectual content to reflect the views of folks who took the time to attend, and more importantly that the process was inclusive and accountable, that each one was thanked for their participation, large or small as contributing to a change in the energy not just in the room, but also in our everyday lives. That we now can smile at each other in the playgrounds, in the parks, in the grocery stores, in the churches, in the movie houses and take the time to talk to our Fedex guy, to our cable guy or even offer a drink to our postman or a banana to our sweating gardener who mows our lawn and we see folks just take the time to be a role model, imitating the goodness they see in the First Family.
So my zeal in the campaign has been transferred to writing daily for a community newspaper, harvesting my fellow community folks' goodness, goodwill and generosity, hoping to immortalize and memorialize them, the unsung, everyday heroes who are rhizomes, whose roots are spread to the thickness of the soil, who stay rooted, yet grow new nodes and stalks that bloom into new flowers, some with fragrance for all of us community folks to enjoy. And my community is becoming larger, no longer just Filpinos, but also amongst my extended family: Chinese, Honduran, Japanese, Blacks and French. Yes, our family is growing since the elections.
Website Shadowed Some, But not ALL. In October, when the website no longer can track my phone banking activities in different field places in Los Angeles, while I searched for who has the best method on the ground floor, I stopped logging as much into the website. And as intense as I got into the campaign, covering even TV programs to explain why Obama, which is not covered in the website, and writing more community newspaper stories, which is also not covered in the website, the irony of all ironies, that is when my ranking of 10 on the mybarackobama.com website declined to 9, one day, and when i asked the basis of that ranking score going down, my score was again diminished to 8. As my ground activities intensified, my website score diminished, which only tells me that scoring kept in the website is no longer reliable and credible. But my conscience reminds me to keep going for my ideals.
Well, guess what folks, my motivation still stayed strong. After all, I did not organize for Obama because of my ego, I self-organized for Obama because I sensed his luminous human spirit, the shine in his character, the shine in how he delights in seeing his family, how he is a very decent person who loves people, how he treats everyone with respect. Of course, he gets testy, and the media writes up about it, particularly when suddenly the children are being included in his media interviews, when he and his wife have not quite precleared and prepared the children. To me, he and his wife are decent parents who do not commercialize their children for their own purposes and respect their privacy and right to say no to public events.
Zeal for Obama not the Democratic Party. And by the way, let it be known to the Obama HQ staff, that Obama inspired me to self-organize, not the Democratic Party who has been recruiting me to get involved for years now, who has yet to have me convinced that the Democratic Party is a genuine, service-oriented party, and it is a party that is beyond multiple selfish agendas of making a candidate win, as that will never be why I will never give up my nights, weekends, days, to simply get someone elected.
I gave up my family time so my family can have a better future, I can now enjoy our holidays this thanksgiving because I know I have installed into office, as 68,900,000 more, a decent man who will put the interests of the American people, the majority of the people first, before his pocketbooks or his future or his legacy, I gave up my precious time to elect a decent MAN OF PRINCIPLES, and let it be known, I am not going to be deceived by pundits, nor taken by decisive instructionns from the top of party leaders who want to use me like I was a piece of merchandise.
You just don't get it, my allegiance and love for this country to reach its American ideals and potentials for inclusive union, and my zeal for principles will not be for sale! For in selling it, I will betray my deepest self and my conscience, who I have to live by and exist with 24/7 all days and all years of my life.
Yes, there are many of us, in fact, perhaps a lot of the more than 68,900,000 voters who pledged them for Obama, you just have to take pause that folks will sacrifice their TIME, TALENTs and TREASUREs to attain an America that has a HEART!!
Yes, it is the heart of a Nation that we are fighting for, not the DEMOCRATIC PARTY and President Elect Barack Obama got it right the first time he ran and because he got it right, we are there for him!
I'm about to head to Grant Park to talk to everyone gathered there, but I wanted to write to you first. We just made history. And I don't want you to forget how we did it. You made history every single day during this campaign -- every day you knocked on doors, made a donation, or talked to your family, friends, and neighbors about why you believe it's time for change. I want to thank all of you who gave your time, talent, and passion to this campaign. We have a lot of work to do to get our country back on track, and I'll be in touch soon about what comes next. But I want to be very clear about one thing... All of this happened because of you. Thank you, Barack
The votes are in from Dixville Notch, NH, all 21 of them. 6 for McCain and 15 for Barack Obama!
They haven't elected a Democratic President since 1968!
Find a polling place near you at Last Call for Change.
"In one week, at this defining moment in history, you can give this country the change we need.... We can't afford to slow down, sit back, or let up for one day, one minute, or one second in this last week. Not now. Not when so much is at stake." For more, select link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XDw5_d0M-wc&NR=1